Difference Between Gold Fund vs Gold ETF

What is a Gold ETF?

What are Gold Mutual Funds?

What is the Difference Between Gold ETF and Gold Mutual Fund?

Understanding the differences between gold funds and gold ETFs is essential. Here are several key differences between them:

Aspect Gold ETF Gold Mutual Fund
Nature of Investment Invests directly in physical gold and tracks its market price. Invests in Gold ETFs or related assets indirectly.
Mode of Holding Held in a demat account like shares. Held in mutual fund units; no demat account required.
Liquidity Highly liquid; traded on stock exchanges during market hours. Redeemable through the mutual fund company; liquidity depends on the fund house.
Expense Ratio Lower expense ratio due to passive management. The expense ratio is slightly higher due to active fund management.
Investment Amount Minimum 1 unit (approx. 1 gram of gold). You can start with as low as ₹500 in SIP mode.
Taxation Treated as non-equity, taxed as debt funds with indexation benefits after 3 years. Taxed similarly to Gold ETFs as a non-equity investment.
Management Style Passively managed, directly tracking gold prices. Actively managed investments in gold ETFs and other gold-related instruments.
Suitability Suitable for investors who directly invest through the dematerialised accounts to track the movement prices of gold. This type of mutual fund may be suitable for acquiring gold for those without a non-demat account.
SIP Gold ETFs do not allow SIPs directly, as they are traded like stocks on exchanges. Gold Mutual Funds allow SIPs, enabling investors to invest regularly in small amounts.
Exit Load Generally, Gold ETFs do not have an exit load unless sold within a short period. Some Gold Mutual Funds may impose an exit load if units are sold within a specified period (usually 1 year).
Demat Account Gold ETFs require a Demat account to hold and trade units. Gold Mutual Funds do not require a Demat account and can be held in a regular one.
Mode of Purchase Purchased and traded on stock exchanges such as NSE and BSE. That one has to purchase through AMC or mutual fund platforms.

Pros of Investing in Gold ETFs and Gold Funds

Gold ETFs and Gold Funds offer easy access to gold investments, each with advantages. The pros of both options will help you choose the one that best fits your investment goals and preferences. Here's a breakdown of their key benefits:

Benefit Pros of Investing in Gold ETF Pros of Investing in Gold Mutual Funds
Direct Exposure to Gold Offers direct exposure to gold price risk, benchmarked to physical gold prices. No direct exposure to physical gold. But it provides indirect gold market exposure.
Liquidity Easily bought or sold during trading hours on stock exchanges. It can be bought or sold through mutual fund platforms but may have limited liquidity.
Lower Expense Ratio Generally, the management expense ratio is lower compared to gold mutual funds. Management fees tend to be higher than ETFs due to active management.
Transparency Real-time price tracking ensures high pricing transparency. Price transparency is lower as fund prices are updated once a day.
No Lock-in Period It can be traded anytime during market hours with no lock-in restrictions. There may be lock-in periods depending on the scheme.
Accessibility Accessible to investors with a demat account and brokerage account. Accessible to average traders without direct access to stock exchanges or demat accounts.
Diversification Focuses solely on gold as the asset class. May invest in gold mining companies and other related assets for diversification.

Cons of Investing in Gold ETFs and Gold Funds

Investors who buy Gold ETFs or Gold Funds can access gold markets without owning physical metal, although both face specific disadvantages. Analysing the cons of these investment possibilities will assist you in your decision process. Here are a few of them:

Limitations Cons of Investing in Gold ETF Cons of Investing in Gold Mutual Funds
Demat Account Mandatory A demat and trading account is required, which may be inconvenient for small investors. No demat account is required; however, the investment platform might have limitations.
Brokerage Fees ETFs attract brokerage fees based on the transaction, similar to shares. There are no brokerage fees. However, there are higher management fees due to active management.
No SIP Option Gold ETFs cannot be purchased via SIP mode, making systematic investment inconvenient. SIP options are available for mutual funds, allowing systematic investments.
Exposure Direct exposure to the price movements of gold. These are invested into gold ETFs that may conflict with the actual price of gold.
Liquidity It can be easily bought or sold during market hours. Redemptions depend on the fund house and may take one or two days to complete.
Taxation Tax treatment depends on the investor's holding period and capital gains. Tax treatment is similar to debt funds, with indexation benefits available after 3 years.

Gold ETF or Gold Mutual Fund - Which is Better?

FAQs about Gold MF vs Gold ETF

How do gold ETFs trade?

up-arrow
Gold ETFs act like shares traded on the stock market with real-time pricing, implying that the investor can buy or sell at any time during the stock exchange business.

How do you trade off the gold mutual funds?

up-arrow
Gold mutual funds are purchased for and sold through fund houses at Net Asset Value or NAV, with all the transactions occurring at the market's close.

Which is more liquid: gold ETF or gold mutual fund?

up-arrow

Gold ETFs can be traded anytime during market hours and are more liquid than gold mutual funds, which are traded only at the NAV aftermarket closing.

Which has lower expense ratios, gold ETF or gold mutual funds?

up-arrow

Often, gold ETFs have lower expense ratios than more active gold mutual funds because the former track the price of gold and do not actively manage assets.

Which is better for long-term investment gold ETF or gold fund?

up-arrow
Gold mutual funds could be advantageous for long-term investors because of management and diversification, while gold ETFs are more beneficial to inactive investors.

How much is the minimum investment in a gold ETF?

up-arrow

Most gold ETFs require investors to start investing with at least one unit; hence, the minimum investment amount is the price of one unit in the ETF.

How much is the minimum investment in a gold mutual fund?

up-arrow
Gold Mutual Funds often have a lower minimum investment requirement, making them accessible for small investors.

What has better tax treatment gold ETF or gold mutual fund?

up-arrow
Traders using gold ETFs will be subject to long-term capital gains tax if they hold them for more than three years, while gold mutual funds generally have higher taxes depending on the type of mutual fund they are.

Are gold ETFs suitable investments for small investors?

up-arrow

Yes, gold ETFs are suitable investments for small investors because most have low investment requirements per unit.

Are gold ETFs a physical gold investment?

up-arrow

No, it is not so. Gold ETFs mirror the price of gold, and gold bullion, such as coins and bars, can be purchased separately.

Which is cheaper when investing frequently: gold mutual funds or gold ETFs?

up-arrow

Gold mutual funds, particularly SIPs, are more suitable for daily small investments than gold ETFs.

Which is better, gold ETF or gold mutual fund?

up-arrow
It depends on your investment goals and risk appetite; gold ETFs offer more flexibility and lower costs, while gold mutual funds may suit those preferring managed investments.

Are investments in gold mutual funds safer than gold ETFs?

up-arrow

Both are relatively safe, but gold mutual funds may have additional risks due to active management, while gold ETFs directly track gold prices.

Why choose a gold ETF over a gold mutual fund?

up-arrow

Gold ETFs offer lower expense ratios, better liquidity, and direct tracking of the price of gold, making them a cost-effective and straightforward option for gold exposure.

What is the primary difference between gold ETFs and gold mutual funds?

up-arrow

Gold ETFs are traded on exchanges and track the price of gold directly, whereas gold mutual funds are actively managed funds that invest in gold-related instruments.

Disclaimer

up-arrow

  • This is an informative article provided on 'as is' basis for awareness purpose only and not intended as a professional advice. The content of the article is derived from various open sources across the Internet. Digit Life Insurance is not promoting or recommending any aspect in the article or its correctness. Please verify the information and your requirement before taking any decisions.
  • All the figures reflected in the article are for illustrative purposes. The premium for Coverage that one buys depends on various factors including customer requirements, eligibility, age, demography, insurance provider, product, coverage amount, term and other factors
  • Tax Benefits, if applicable depend on the Tax Regime opted by the individual and the applicable tax provision. Please consult your Tax consultant before making any decision.

Latest News

Currently there are no news to show.

Read More

Renew & Download Policy Document, Check Challan, Credit Score, PUC & more

Anytime, Anywhere. Only on Digit App!

google-play-icon

Rated App

app-store-icon

Rated App