Difference Between Open-ended vs Closed-ended Mutual Funds

What are Open-Ended Mutual Funds?

What are Closed-Ended Mutual Funds?

Key Differences Between Open-Ended Funds and Closed-Ended Funds

Close-ended and open-ended mutual funds are the two types of mutual funds. Knowing the differences would help the investors make the right choice depending on the value they need. Here's a breakdown of the typical differences between the two:

Aspect Open-End Mutual Funds Closed-End Mutual Funds
Definition An open-ended fund is a type of mutual fund that allows investors to buy or sell units at any time. A closed-end fund is an investment that raises capital by issuing a fixed number of shares at its inception and then invests that capital in financial assets.
Structure There is no fixed number of shares; shares are redeemed per investor demand. Fixed number of shares; no new shares are issued after the initial offering.
Liquidity Highly liquid; shares can be bought or sold directly from the fund anytime. Limited liquidity: Shares can only be bought or sold on the stock exchange.
Subscription It can be subscribed to through a stock exchange via a Demat account. It can be subscribed to through mutual fund distributors or online platforms without a Demat account.
Investment Mode Investment is done by purchasing units of the ETF through a Demat account on the stock exchange. Investment is done by purchasing mutual fund units from asset management companies (AMCs).
Maturity No fixed maturity; can be traded anytime on the stock exchange. No fixed maturity; however, the redemption value depends on the NAV, and funds can be redeemed at any time.
Listing Listed on stock exchanges, and units are traded like stocks. Not listed on exchanges; units are bought and sold through the AMC at the NAV.
AUM (Assets Under Management) AUM is typically smaller as it directly tracks the price of physical gold. AUM can vary widely as it may invest in various gold-related assets, including ETFs and mining stocks.
Pricing Shares are priced based on the Net Asset Value (NAV), which is calculated daily. Shares trade on the stock exchange at market prices, which may differ from NAV.
Management Actively managed or passively managed, with continuous investment inflows. Actively managed, with a fixed capital base and no inflows after the IPO.
Investment Period Open-ended investors can invest or redeem at any time. Closed-ended investors must hold until the fund is liquidated or sold on the exchange.
Minimum Investment Lower minimum investment requirements. There may be higher minimum investments due to initial public offerings (IPOs).
Risk and Volatility Lower volatility, as it directly tracks the NAV. Higher volatility due to market price fluctuations based on supply and demand.
Management Fees Generally lower management fees for passively managed funds. Typically, higher management fees are due to active management and trading.
Tax Implications Investors may face capital gains taxes when they redeem shares. Taxable events occur based on the sale or transfer of shares on the stock exchange.

Advantages of Open-End and Closed-End Mutual Funds

Open-end and closed-end mutual funds differ in terms of investment advantages. The key advantages of each are given below:

Advantages Open-end Mutual Fund Closed-end Mutual Fund
Professional Management A professional management company manages these funds that would give good quality management and good exposure to the underlying securities. Expert managers pick the best portfolios for efficient return maximisation over an investment term.
Diversification Invested in different assets, spreading risk all over sectors and industries, capping loss when some securities fall behind. Not explicitly, but it can be structured for diversification.
Easy Access Low minimum investments, accessible to each one, and offers systematic investment through SIPs. Not applicable as investments are made in a fixed number of shares at launch.
Transparency Regular updates on holdings, performance, and fund fees help investors align with their objectives. Prices are determined by market demand and supply, and they are traded at a premium or discount to NAV.
Economies of Scale Taps resources pooled from several investors. This enhances expanded portfolios, lowering trading costs. This ensures low expenses. Directly not available, but with fixed capital, benefits are evident.
Higher Return Potential Investors benefit from steady growth and fund performance. Potential to buy shares at a discount and sell at a premium for enhanced returns.

Disadvantages of Open-End and Closed-End Mutual Funds

A closed-ended and open-ended mutual fund has several disadvantages that all investors should consider. This helps you arrive at a wiser decision for your investments. So check the table below to know about the disadvantages of both the funds:

Disadvantages Open-end Mutual Fund Closed-end Mutual Fund
Market Risk Open-end mutual funds are subject to market fluctuations and risks, which reduce their value. Investors can incur certain losses when the market is bearish. The market price of the underlying shares of close-ended funds is subject to market risk. Depending on the stock, it may undergo volatility.
Less Control Investors cannot control precisely what securities the fund manager buys or sells, which may not suit those who want a more hands-on and direct approach to investing. Investors have no control over portfolio decisions.
Tax Implications Open-end mutual funds may distribute capital gains to investors, which can result in possible tax liabilities. Even if the investor has not sold the shares, the gains may be subject to taxation. Capital gains taxes may apply upon selling shares.
Fixed Investment Period Not applicable, as investors can invest and redeem as needed. Investors should generally hold their investments until the fund's maturity or until they liquidate them on the stock exchange.

Which is Better: Open-Ended or Closed-Ended Mutual Funds?

FAQs about Open-ended vs Closed-ended Funds

How do liquidity and redemption differ between open-ended and closed-ended mutual funds?

up-arrow
Open-ended funds offer high liquidity, allowing redemption at any time based on NAV. Closed-ended funds, however, can only be purchased or sold on the stock exchange and have limited liquidity.

Can I purchase units of open-ended mutual funds at any time?

up-arrow
Yes, an investor may buy units of an open-ended fund at any time, as the fund continuously accepts investments.

Do closed-ended funds offer the same flexibility when buying as open-ended funds?

up-arrow
No, closed-ended funds can only be bought during the NFO period, after which they are available for trading on the stock exchange.

Are closed-ended mutual funds subject to market price fluctuations?

up-arrow
Yes, closed-ended funds can trade at a premium or discount to their NAV on the exchange, causing potential price fluctuations.

Can I redeem my investment in a closed-ended fund before maturity?

up-arrow
No, you cannot redeem your investment in a closed-ended fund before its maturity date. You can only sell your shares on the stock exchange to other investors.

Do open-ended funds have a fixed number of shares?

up-arrow
No, open-ended funds continuously issue and redeem units, so the number of units is variable.

How do I determine the price of an open-ended mutual fund?

up-arrow
An open-ended fund's price (NAV) is calculated daily based on the value of its assets.

Are closed-ended funds more suitable for short-term investors?

up-arrow
No, closed-end funds are for long-term investors because such funds have fixed maturity periods.

Can I access my money quickly in an open-ended fund?

up-arrow
Yes, since you can redeem units anytime, open-ended funds must be financially liquid so you can quickly access your investment.

What happens if there is a large-scale redemption in an open-ended fund?

up-arrow
In large-scale redemption, the fund may need to liquidate assets or position itself to drive the action, which could affect the other investors' performance and returns.

What is the difference between an open-ended fund and a closed-ended fund?

up-arrow
Open-ended funds allow investors to buy and sell units anytime at the NAV, while closed-ended funds have a fixed number of units and are traded on exchanges after the New Fund Offer (NFO).

Which is better, an open-end fund or a closed-end fund?

up-arrow

It depends on your needs: open-ended funds offer liquidity, while closed-ended funds may offer the potential for higher returns but with less liquidity.

What are the main types of closed-end funds?

up-arrow
The main types of closed-end funds are equity, debt, balanced, and sector-specific, each with a fixed maturity period.

Is it possible to redeem closed-end funds after the New Fund Offer (NFO) period ends?

up-arrow
Yes, you can redeem or sell closed-end funds on the stock exchange after the NFO period ends.

Why is it called a closed-end fund?

up-arrow

It's called a closed-end fund because it has a fixed number of shares that are not redeemable, and units can only be bought or sold on the stock exchange.

Is ELSS a closed-end fund?

up-arrow
No, ELSS (Equity Linked Savings Schemes) is an open-ended mutual fund with a 3-year lock-in period.

Which is a more tax-efficient, open-ended fund or closed-ended fund?

up-arrow
Both fund types are tax-efficient, but closed-ended funds might offer more tax-saving opportunities due to their fixed structure and long-term investment focus.

Disclaimer

up-arrow

  • This is an informative article provided on 'as is' basis for awareness purpose only and not intended as a professional advice. The content of the article is derived from various open sources across the Internet. Digit Life Insurance is not promoting or recommending any aspect in the article or its correctness. Please verify the information and your requirement before taking any decisions.
  • All the figures reflected in the article are for illustrative purposes. The premium for Coverage that one buys depends on various factors including customer requirements, eligibility, age, demography, insurance provider, product, coverage amount, term and other factors
  • Tax Benefits, if applicable depend on the Tax Regime opted by the individual and the applicable tax provision. Please consult your Tax consultant before making any decision.

Latest News

Currently there are no news to show.

Read More

Renew & Download Policy Document, Check Challan, Credit Score, PUC & more

Anytime, Anywhere. Only on Digit App!

google-play-icon

Rated App

app-store-icon

Rated App