Difference Between Active Funds vs Passive Funds

What is an Actively Managed Portfolio?

What is a Passively Managed Portfolio?

Key Differences Between Active Fund and Passive Fund

Knowing the key difference between active and passive funds is necessary if you are about to invest. It can help us decide the best funds to suit your investment strategy. The following table depicts the key difference:

Basis Actively Managed Funds Passively Managed Funds
Management Approach Fund managers actively make investment decisions to outperform the market. Follows a specific index or benchmark (e.g., Nifty 50, Sensex) with minimal intervention from fund managers.
Objective Aim to beat the market by leveraging expertise and market analysis. Aim to replicate the performance of a market index without seeking to outperform it.
Cost The higher expense ratio typically ranges from 1-2.5%. It is due to active management and research costs. The lower expense ratio is usually 0.05-1%, which involves minimal research and management effort.
Risk Higher risk as decisions depend on the fund manager's expertise and market timing. Lower risk as it tracks a diversified market index, reducing dependency on a manager.
Returns Potentially higher returns but not guaranteed; for example, active equity funds in India delivered 10-15% CAGR over the last decade. Provides market-linked returns that closely match the benchmark, e.g., passive index funds in India delivered around 8-12% CAGR.
Transparency Less transparent due to frequent portfolio changes and manager discretion. Highly transparent as holdings mirror the index composition, with periodic disclosures.
Flexibility Fund managers can adjust the portfolio according to the market conditions. No flexibility, as it strictly follows the index.
Investor Suitability Suitable for investors looking at high returns with higher risks. Ideal for conservative investors preferring a steady, market-matching return.
Performance Monitoring Calls for constant observation of the performance of the fund manager. Easy to monitor as it simply mirrors the index.
Tax Efficiency Less tax-efficient due to higher portfolio turnover, which may lead to more short-term capital gains. More tax-efficient as they typically have lower turnover, reducing the frequency of taxable events.

Advantages of Active Funds and Passive Funds

Active funds and passive funds come with many advantages and disadvantages. Knowing them before making the choice is necessary. Below are the pros of active funds and passive funds:

Aspect Pros of Active Funds Pros of Passive Funds
Potential for Higher Returns They are designed to be better than market indexes. If the fund manager's strategy and portfolio selection are correct, superior returns can be possible. These funds deliver returns in line with the benchmark. They offer steady and predictable performance.
Flexibility in Investment Fund managers can use this portfolio to seize market trends. It also covers economic changes or newly found opportunities. So, it helps monitor funds actively to reduce losses. Passive funds have minimal expense ratios. Their straightforward approach to tracking an index makes them cost-effective.
Diversified Strategies The money employs sector rotation or stock-picking strategies. These strategies can result in considerable gains in favourable circumstances, and diversification provides reduced risks. Index funds help decrease the danger of exposure to specific stock volatility. They distribute portions of capital around various sectors and companies, diversifying exposure instead.
Niche Market Investments They can invest in specialized or less-explored segments, such as small caps or emerging markets. This is a means of diversification other than with regular indices. Fewer trades allow for lower capital gains taxation, making passive funds tax friendlier. Investors retain more significant portions of their returns.

Disadvantages of Active Funds and Passive Funds

Both funds are a great choice for mutual funds investment, but considering the disadvantages is crucial before deciding. Here are the key drawbacks:

Aspect Cons of Active Funds Cons of Passive Funds
High Cost Generally, active funds are relatively more expensive in terms of expense ratios. In these, returns are dampened by the research and management fees, which are also referred to as the expense ratio. Since they cannot alter their investments according to market conditions, they may not be able to seize short-term market advantages.
Unpredictable Performance Since this strategy relies on the expertise of a fund manager, there is no high probability of consistently outperforming the market. Thus, the performance of the fund remains vulnerable to market fluctuations. They are only built to replicate whatever the market index does, so investors forgo potential excess gains during bull markets.
High Volatility If the market goes wrong or there are wrong investment calls, volatility can be increased using an active strategy. Thus, an incorrect prediction can cause a loss of funds and returns. Returns are tied solely to index performance, subjecting investors to index-specific risks.

Active Funds or Passive Funds - Which is Better?

When choosing an active vs passive fund, the investor should consider his financial goals, tolerance for risk, and market expectations.

1. Performance

Active funds take advantage of short-term market volatility to achieve better performance. However, passive funds follow the market index's performance and give steady returns.

2. Flexibility and Risk

Active funds change according to the market situation but with higher risks. Passive funds mirror the index, meaning there is less risk but less return. If you are a new investor, passive funds would suit you better.

3. Costs

Active funds are costlier because of the management fees. Passive funds are cheaper since their expense ratio is low. Therefore, passive funds are more lucrative for conservative investors.

4. Market Conditions

Active funds perform better in a good market but are more susceptible to volatility. Passive funds are consistent in both bearish and volatile markets.

FAQs about Active Funds vs Passive Funds

Why do passive funds have lower fees than active funds?

up-arrow
Passive funds have low fees because they follow a pre-set index with minimal trading and research. Active funds cost more due to expert-led research, trading, and management.

Do active funds perform better in down markets?

up-arrow
Yes, active funds may do better in down markets if managers take defensive steps. However, that will depend on their skill and timing.

Can passive funds beat the market?

up-arrow
No, passive funds cannot beat the market because they are a mirror of it. However, they can outperform active funds over time because of lower fees.

Over the long term, how many active funds outperform their benchmark?

up-arrow
Only 20-30% of active funds beat their benchmarks over 10-15 years because of high fees and inconsistent performance.

What is "closet indexing," and why is it undesirable?

up-arrow
Closet indexing occurs when an active fund tracks an index but charges a high fee, providing a bad value for the money.

Do all passive funds have equal weight?

up-arrow
No, some track a broad index, while others focus on a sector, region, or factor, such as dividends or growth.

What are the risks associated with passive investing?

up-arrow
Passive investments do not respond to market changes and may concentrate on popular sectors or laggard indices.

Do active funds perform better in emerging markets?

up-arrow
Yes, active funds can perform better in emerging markets by exploiting inefficiencies and mispricing.

How would ESG considerations differ for active and passive funds?

up-arrow
Active funds can customize ESG portfolios, while passive funds rely on broad, less precise ESG indices.

Are ETFs active or passive?

up-arrow
ETFs can track a passive index or be actively managed, offering low costs and flexibility in trading.

What are the tax implications of passive funds?

up-arrow
The passive funds would have fewer taxable events because their turnover is lower than the active funds, generating higher capital gains taxes.

Do active funds outperform passive funds in terms of risk reduction?

up-arrow
Yes, active funds hedge their risks better by diversifying non-indexed assets rather than passive funds that strictly follow the index.

How do liquidity concerns impact active and passive funds?

up-arrow
Active funds hold less liquid assets, whereas passive funds are more liquid; they follow widely traded indices.

Why do people continue to invest in active funds?

up-arrow
Active funds may outperform in stressed markets and emerging economies by exploiting market inefficiencies that passive funds miss.

Disclaimer

up-arrow

  • This is an informative article provided on 'as is' basis for awareness purpose only and not intended as a professional advice. The content of the article is derived from various open sources across the Internet. Digit Life Insurance is not promoting or recommending any aspect in the article or its correctness. Please verify the information and your requirement before taking any decisions.
  • All the figures reflected in the article are for illustrative purposes. The premium for Coverage that one buys depends on various factors including customer requirements, eligibility, age, demography, insurance provider, product, coverage amount, term and other factors
  • Tax Benefits, if applicable depend on the Tax Regime opted by the individual and the applicable tax provision. Please consult your Tax consultant before making any decision.

Latest News

Currently there are no news to show.

Read More

Renew & Download Policy Document, Check Challan, Credit Score, PUC & more

Anytime, Anywhere. Only on Digit App!

google-play-icon

Rated App

app-store-icon

Rated App