Difference Between Mutual Funds vs Hedge Funds & Its Taxation

What are Mutual Funds?

What are Hedge Funds?

Difference Between Mutual Funds and Hedge Funds

Understanding the difference between mutual and hedge funds enables one to make an informed decision. The table below depicts the key differences between mutual and hedge funds:

Aspect Mutual Funds Hedge Funds
Investor Base Accessible to the public, targeting the masses at different income levels. Available to HNIs and institutional investors.
Objective Strives for steady growth, ensuring returns as close to, though preferably more than, market returns. For aggressive growth, use high-risk tactics to generate maximum return.
Management and Ownership The fund managers are professional. The latter have no personal interest in the fund. Managers invest their funds within the fund, aligning interests with investors.
Regulations Tight regulations from bodies like SEBI govern it to ensure transparency and protect investors. More relaxed regulations offer greater strategy flexibility with higher risks.
Transparency Full disclosure of financial statements and regular performance updates to all investors. Limited transparency: strategies are confidential, and only select information is shared.
Fees Charges lower fees, usually as a percentage of assets under management. Imposes more extensive fees comprising management and performance fees.
Liquidity Well-liquid, hence allowing for daily purchasing or redemption of shares at NAV. Less liquid with restricted redeemability and possible lock-up periods.
Investment Strategy Conservative: In each strategy, publicly traded securities are used for stable returns with lower risk. Aggressive tactics such as leverage and short selling target high returns with higher risks.
Holding Period Investors should hold for 3-5 years; investments can be redeemed or sold anytime. Hedge funds have a lock-up period of 1-3 years to execute high-risk strategies.
National Regulations Subject to regulation by authorities like SEBI and SEC for investor protection. It is less regulated and has more flexibility in strategy, but it comes with higher risks.
Investor Count & Investment Size It is wide-based, with investments ranging from as low as ₹500. Exclusively for high-net-worth individuals (HNIs) and institutional investors with more significant minimum investments.
Tax Taxed based on the holding period (STCG or LTCG) with favourable tax treatment for long-term investments. Taxation can vary based on the strategy. It may involve higher taxes on short-term gains due to aggressive strategies.

Types of Mutual Funds

There are several types of mutual funds available in the market. Knowing them makes us choose the type that suits our financial goals and risks. The following are the major types of mutual funds:

Fund Type Description
Equity Funds Equity funds are mutual funds that invest in shares of different companies. They offer higher returns but are volatile, depending on market conditions.
Debt Funds Investments in securities that generate fixed revenue, such as treasury bills, corporate bonds, and money market instruments, with a pre-determined maturity date and interest rate.
Hybrid Funds A combination of equity and debt funds allows investment in multiple assets through a single fund. It performs well in the long term, with varying equity-debt combinations.
Money Market Funds Also called money market mutual funds, they invest in short-term, high-liquid instruments like cash and cash equivalents, often with low-level risk.

Types of Hedge Funds

There are four different types of hedge funds available in the market. We can make an informed decision about our investment once we know the risks and returns. The following depicts the types of hedge funds:

Type Description
Global Macro Hedge Fund Focuses on macroeconomic factors and financial conditions, such as inflation rates, to profit from market volatility.
Relative Value Hedge Fund Aimed at making a temporary price difference profit between closely related securities with lower risk and larger returns.
Activist Hedge Fund Holds a significant stake in companies to influence operations or financial decisions by persuading boards and management for changes.
Equity Hedge Fund Invests in equities and derivatives (both long and short) to generate returns from global equity markets while minimising downside risks.

How are Mutual Funds and Hedge Funds Taxed?

  STCG (Short-Term Capital Gains Tax) LTCG (Long-Term Capital Gains Tax)
Fund Categories Pre-Budget 2024 Post-Budget 2024 Pre-Budget 2024 Post-Budget 2024
Indian Equity Funds/ETFs & Equity-Oriented Hybrids 15% (if held for less than 1 year) 20% (if held for less than 1 year) 10% (on gains above ₹1 lakh if held for over 1 year) 12.5% (on gains above ₹ 1.25 lakh if held for over 1 year)
Debt Funds/ETF & Debt-Oriented Hybrids* Slab rate Slab rate Slab rate Slab rate
All FOFs (that hold less than 65% in debt)/International/Gold Funds/ETFs** Slab rate Slab rate if held for less than 2 years Slab rate 12.5% if held for over 2 years

The presumptions that are made due to a few grey areas are:

  • Investments made before April 1, 2023, will attract a 12.5% tax if sold after 2 years.
  • The new rule applies from April 1, 2025. Redemptions made before will be taxed at the usual slab rate.

Which is Better - Mutual Funds or Hedge Funds?

The choice depends on the financial goals of the investor, the risk tolerance, and the investment horizon.

1. Risk and Return

Mutual funds offer moderate returns with lower risk. They are suitable for long-term investors who want stable growth. Hedge funds have the potential for higher returns. However, they carry more risk because of complex investment techniques, which makes them unsuitable for conservative investors.

2. Accessibility and Minimum Investment

Mutual funds are open to everyone; any individual can invest even with the minimum initial investment. Hedge funds need a very high minimum investment. Only wealthy individuals and big companies can usually invest in them.

3. Liquidity

Mutual funds are easy to buy and sell, so they are flexible for investors. Investors can withdraw their money daily. Hedge funds have restrictions on withdrawals. Investors may have to wait months or even years to recover their money, making hedge funds less lucrative for new investors.

FAQs about Mutual Funds vs Hedge Funds

What is the main difference between mutual funds and hedge funds?

up-arrow
Mutual funds collect money from the public (all investors in general), whereas hedge funds are for high-net-worth individuals with aggressive strategies.

Who can invest in mutual funds and hedge funds?

up-arrow
Any individual can invest in mutual funds. However, hedge funds are reserved for accredited investors such as HNIs and institutions.

What is the investment objective of both mutual funds and hedge funds?

up-arrow
Mutual fund investments aim for steady growth. At the same time, a hedge fund seeks high returns by using complex strategies.

What level of transparency do mutual funds and hedge funds provide?

up-arrow
Mutual funds disclose all information, while hedge funds limit transparency for strategy protection.

Who should invest in hedge funds?

up-arrow
Hedge funds are appropriate for experienced investors with high-risk tolerance, preferably high-network individuals.

What is the difference in liquidity between mutual funds and hedge funds?

up-arrow
Mutual funds have daily liquidity, while hedge funds have lock-in periods and restricted withdrawals.

Mutual funds or hedge funds: Which is best for long-term investors?

up-arrow
Mutual funds suit long-term investors; hedge funds suit high-risk, goal-specific investors.

Can beginners invest in hedge funds instead of mutual funds?

up-arrow
Mutual funds are the best for new investors because mutual funds have fewer risks and are easy to manage. So, beginners are not advised to invest in hedge funds.

Are Hedge Funds legal in India?

up-arrow
Yes, Hedge Funds are legal in India. They are categorised under the Alternative Investment Fund (AIF) category and regulated by SEBI.

Why is it called a hedge fund?

up-arrow
It is called a hedge fund because it follows the " hedging " strategy against market risks, which results in positive returns regardless of market risks.

Do mutual funds and hedge funds reveal holdings to the investors?

up-arrow
Divulging investors' holdings regularly is mandatory in mutual funds. However, hedge funds have the flexibility not to reveal holdings to a certain extent.

Which is better: mutual funds or hedge funds?

up-arrow
Mutual funds are the best for stable, long-term growth with lesser risk. Hedge funds are apt for high-net-worth individuals willing to take more significant risks for better returns.

Are hedge funds riskier than mutual funds?

up-arrow
Yes, hedge funds are riskier because they use an aggressive strategy: leverage and short selling. A mutual fund tends to be of lower risk as it spreads investments.

What are the risks associated with hedge funds and mutual funds?

up-arrow
Mutual funds are involved in high risks through leverage strategies. Hedge funds bear lower risks, though the market may affect them.

How are mutual funds and hedge funds regulated?

up-arrow
Agencies like SEBI and SEC strictly regulate mutual funds to ensure investor protection. Hedge funds have fewer regulations, offering more flexibility but higher risks.

Which is more tax-efficient: hedge funds or mutual funds?

up-arrow
Mutual funds are more tax-efficient than hedge funds. Hedge funds are relatively expensive, mainly because long-term capital gains require more tax compliance.

What is the cost associated with hedge funds and mutual funds?

up-arrow
Mutual funds are relatively cheaper, with an expense ratio of 0.1% to 2%, which pays for management and operational fees. Hedge Funds charge more, a 2% management fee, and a 20% performance fee on profits because they are very active and have a more complex strategy.

Disclaimer

up-arrow

  • This is an informative article provided on 'as is' basis for awareness purpose only and not intended as a professional advice. The content of the article is derived from various open sources across the Internet. Digit Life Insurance is not promoting or recommending any aspect in the article or its correctness. Please verify the information and your requirement before taking any decisions.
  • All the figures reflected in the article are for illustrative purposes. The premium for Coverage that one buys depends on various factors including customer requirements, eligibility, age, demography, insurance provider, product, coverage amount, term and other factors
  • Tax Benefits, if applicable depend on the Tax Regime opted by the individual and the applicable tax provision. Please consult your Tax consultant before making any decision.

Latest News

Currently there are no news to show.

Read More

Renew & Download Policy Document, Check Challan, Credit Score, PUC & more

Anytime, Anywhere. Only on Digit App!

google-play-icon

Rated App

app-store-icon

Rated App