Pure Term Insurance vs Return of Premium vs Permanent Life Insurance

life insurance family protection

Life insurance is important in financial planning since it protects loved ones during an unexpected death. However, choosing the correct coverage can be difficult given the range of options available.

Term insurance, Term Plan with Return of Premium (TROP), and Permanent Life Insurance are the three most prevalent varieties. Each has distinct benefits, costs, and optimal conditions for different people. This article strives to clarify the differences, benefits, and downsides so you can make an informed decision.

Table of Contents

arrow-icon

What is Term Insurance?

term insurance
Term insurance is a straightforward and cost-effective life insurance policy designed to provide financial protection for a specific period (or "term"), typically ranging from 10 to 30 years. The main advantage of term insurance is its affordability, as it only provides a death benefit if the policyholder passes away during the term.

What is Term Plan with Return of Premium (TROP)

term plan with return of premium
Term Plan with Return of Premium (TROP) insurance is a variation of term insurance. It provides a death benefit during the policy term, but if the policyholder outlives the term, all premiums paid are refunded. This unique feature makes ROP policies appealing to those who want life insurance protection but prefer not to lose their investment if they survive the term.

What is Permanent Life Insurance?

permanent life insurance
Permanent life insurance, as the name suggests, provides lifelong coverage. Unlike term insurance, it does not have an expiration date as long as premiums are paid. Permanent policies have a cash value component that grows over time, acting as a savings or investment vehicle.

Difference Between Pure Term Insurance vs Return of Premium vs Permanent Life Insurance

Feature Pure Term Insurance Term Plan with Return of Premium Permanent Life Insurance
Purpose Provides financial protection for a fixed term Offers financial protection + returns premiums if the policyholder survives Provides lifelong coverage with an investment component
Coverage Duration Fixed term (10 - 40 years) Fixed term (10 - 40 years) Lifetime coverage (100 years)
Premiums Lowest Higher than pure term Highest due to investment component
Survival Benefit None Refund of total premiums paid (excluding taxes, riders, etc) Builds cash value + death benefit
Death Benefit Sum assured paid to the nominee Sum assured paid to the nominee Sum assured + accumulated cash value paid to the nominee
Investment Component NA NA Yes (cash value grows over time)
Tax Benefits Premiums qualify for tax dedication under Section 80C, death benefit is tax-free under Section 10(10D) Premiums qualify for tax dedication under Section 80C, death benefit is tax-free under Section 10(10D) Premiums qualify for tax dedication under Section 80C, death benefit is tax-free under Section 10(10D) + tax-free withdrawals
Surrender Value No surrender value No surrender value unless policy is completed Has surrender value based on cash accumulation
Best for Cost-effective pure protection People who want term insurance but dislike losing premiums Those looking for lifelong coverage + wealth accumulation
Flexibility No maturity benefits, only coverage Limited flexibility Can borrow against cash value or withdraw funds
Pros
  • Most affordable for high coverage
  • Simple and easy to understand
  • High sum assured for low premium
  • Provides life cover like pure term insurance
  • Refunds all premiums if the policyholder survives
  • Encourages disciplined savings
  • Provides lifetime coverage
    Builds cash value which can be borrowed or withdrawn)
  • Works as both insurance and an investment
  • Good for estate planning or wealth transfer
Cons
  • No maturity survival benefit
  • No savings or investment component
  • Coverage ends after term completion
  • Higher premium than pure term insurance
  • No investment growth; only premiums are refunded
  • Very high premiums compared to term plans
  • Complex to understand (investment, charges, cash values)
  • Early surrender may lead to financial loss
    Investment returns may be lower than other market options

Cost Comparison of Term Insurance vs Return of Premium vs Permanent Life Insurance

Rajesh, a 35-year-old healthy, non-smoking male, is seeking 1 crore term insurance coverage to secure his family's future. Let's see how each plan costs:

Plan Details Term Life Insurance (20-year term) Return of Premium (20-year term) Permanent Life Insurance
Annual Premium ₹15,100 - ₹18,868 ₹32,704 - ₹40,768 ₹18,396 - ₹23,820
Total Cost ₹3,02,000 - ₹3,77,360 ₹6,54,080 - ₹8,15,360 ₹11,77,344 - ₹15,24,480
(This is the total cost for coverage from age 35 to 99 years. You can pay the premium for 10 to 20 years and receive coverage until age 99).
Return If You Survive ₹0 (The coverage does not pay out if you survive the term.) Full premium returned, so you get back ₹6,54,080 - ₹8,15,360 at the end of the term if you outlive it. NA
Cash value NA NA ₹3,00,000 - ₹6,00,000 (Varies based on policy type and market performance)
Coverage The coverage amount of ₹1 Crore is paid out to the beneficiaries if the policyholder passes away within the 20-year term. The coverage amount of ₹1 Crore is paid out to the beneficiaries if the policyholder passes away within the 20-year term. The coverage amount of ₹1 Crore is paid out to the beneficiaries whenever the policyholder passes away, as long as the premiums are paid.

Disclaimer: The cost comparison provided is for illustrative purposes only and may vary based on individual circumstances, policy terms, and insurance providers. Actual premiums and benefits may differ.

Types of Term Insurance

Several types of term insurance policies are designed to meet different needs. Here are the main types:

Type of Term Insurance Description Pros Cons
Level Term Insurance Death benefits and premiums remain the same throughout the policy term. Predictable premiums, straightforward. No cash value, premiums can be higher than initial premiums of other types.
Renewable Term Insurance It can be renewed annually without a medical exam, but premiums increase with age. No need for a medical exam at renewal; it is flexible. Increasing premiums can become expensive over time.
Convertible Term Insurance Allows conversion to a permanent policy without a medical exam. Flexibility to switch to permanent insurance; no medical exam required for conversion. Higher premiums after conversion, limited conversion period.
Decreasing Term Insurance Death benefit decreases over the term, often used for mortgages or debts. Lower premiums match decreasing financial obligations. Decreasing coverage may not be suitable for long-term needs.
Increasing Term Insurance Death benefits increase over time to keep up with inflation. Increasing coverage is good for growing financial responsibilities. Higher premiums are more complex.

Types of Permanent Life Insurance

Several types of permanent life insurance are designed to meet different needs. Here are the main types:

Type of Permanent Life Insurance Description Pros Cons
Whole Life Insurance Provides lifetime coverage with fixed premiums and a guaranteed death benefit. Accumulates cash value at a guaranteed rate. Stable premiums, guaranteed death benefit, cash value growth. Higher premiums, less flexibility.
Universal Life Insurance Offers flexible premiums and death benefits. Cash value grows based on market interest rates. Flexible premiums, the potential for higher cash value growth. Cash value growth depends on market performance and can be complex.
Variable Universal Life Insurance It combines universal life features with investment options for cash value. Investment options for higher returns and flexible premiums. High risk due to market volatility and complex management.

When to Choose Each Type of Life Insurance?

Term Insurance

Term Insurance with Return of Premium

Permanent Life Insurance

icon

Choose Term Insurance if:

  • You need affordable coverage for a specific period.
  • You have dependents who need temporary financial protection.
  • You don’t require a cash value component.
  • You are looking for a limited budget.
  • You are looking for maximum coverage at a lower cost.
  • You want death benefit protection without any investment component.
  • You want to cover financial responsibilities that will diminish over time, like a mortgage, business loans or children's education.
icon

Choose Term Insurance with Return of Premium (TROP) if:

  • You want a term policy with the potential to get your premiums back.
  • You are willing to pay a higher premium, wanting a return.
  • You prefer a lower-risk approach to life insurance.
  • You are an individual who is uncomfortable with "losing" premiums.
  • You want to combine the benefits of term insurance with a savings element.
icon

Choose Permanent Life Insurance if:

  • You want lifelong coverage with a cash value.
  • You are interested in a life insurance policy that can act as an investment.
  • You have complex financial needs, such as estate planning or wealth transfer.
  • You are looking for a higher budget with investment goals.
  • You want forced savings.
  • You are planning to cover business succession, wealth transfer and special needs planning.

Common Term Life Insurance Riders for Extra Benefits

Riders are additional features that can be added to your life insurance policy to customise it better to meet your needs. Here are some common riders:

Term Insurance and Return of Premium Riders

Common Riders Description
Accidental Death Benefit Rider This rider provides an additional payout if the policyholder dies due to an accident.
Waiver of Premium Rider If the policyholder becomes disabled and cannot work, this rider waives future premiums, allowing the policy to remain active without payment.
Critical Illness Rider This rider pays out a benefit if the policyholder is diagnosed with a critical illness, helping to cover medical expenses.
Income Benefit Rider Provides a regular income to the beneficiary in addition to the lump sum death benefit.
Terminal Illness Rider Allows the insured to access a portion of the death benefit if diagnosed with a terminal illness.

Permanent Life Insurance Riders

Common Riders Description
Guaranteed Insurability Allows the insured to purchase additional coverage at specified times without a medical exam.
Long-Term Care This feature funds long-term care services if the policyholder needs assistance due to chronic illness or disability.
Accelerated Death Benefit Allows the insured to access a portion of the death benefit if diagnosed with a terminal illness.
Child Term This allows parents to add coverage for their children at a reduced cost, ensuring additional protection for the family.

Choosing between term insurance, term insurance with return of premium, and permanent life insurance depends on your unique situation, financial goals, and budget. Term insurance offers affordable protection for specific periods, TROP provides premium returns with higher costs, and permanent insurance combines lifetime coverage with wealth-building features.

 

Consider your current needs, future goals, and financial capacity when making your decision. Remember that insurance needs to change over time, so regular review and adjustment of your coverage is essential. Working with a qualified insurance professional can help you navigate these options and create a protection strategy that aligns with your overall financial plan.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the need for a TROP if I already have a basic term insurance plan?

up-arrow
A basic term plan provides coverage for a specified period and pays out the sum assured only if the insured passes away during the term. A TROP plan refunds the premiums paid if the insured survives the policy term. This can be appealing if you want the security of term insurance with the added benefit of getting your premiums back if you outlive the policy.

Which insurance option has the lowest premiums?

up-arrow
Pure term insurance generally has the lowest premiums compared to other types of life insurance. This is because it provides only life coverage without any savings or investment components, making it a cost-effective option for those looking for high coverage at a low cost.

Who should choose pure term insurance?

up-arrow
Pure term insurance is ideal for individuals looking for affordable life coverage to protect their dependents in case of their untimely death. It is also ideal for young professionals or those with limited budgets who need high coverage at a low premium.

Is permanent life insurance more expensive than term insurance plans?

up-arrow
Yes, permanent life insurance is generally more expensive than term insurance plans. This is because permanent life insurance provides lifelong coverage and includes a savings or investment component (cash value), which increases the policy's overall cost.

Does permanent life insurance always build cash value?

up-arrow

Yes, permanent life insurance builds cash value, but the growth rate varies by policy type:

  • Whole life: Guaranteed growth rate plus possible dividends
  • Universal life: Based on current interest rates
  • Variable life: Based on investment performance

How does the cash value in Permanent Life Insurance work?

up-arrow

The cash value in permanent life insurance is a savings component that grows over time. A portion of your premium payments goes into this cash value account, which accumulates on a tax-deferred basis.

You can borrow against the cash value, withdraw from it, or use it to pay premiums. Depending on the type of permanent life insurance (e.g., whole life, universal life), the cash value grows at a guaranteed rate or based on investment performance.

Can I borrow against my life insurance policy?

up-arrow
You can borrow against the cash value of permanent life insurance policies. Term and ROP policies don’t offer this feature during the coverage period.

Can I convert my term policy to permanent insurance later?

up-arrow
Yes, many term policies include a conversion option that allows you to convert to permanent insurance without a medical exam. However, this must typically be done before a specific age or within the timeframe specified in your policy.

Why are TROP premiums higher than regular term insurance?

up-arrow
TROP premiums are higher because the insurance company return your premiums at a guaranteed cost.

Can I have multiple life insurance policies?

up-arrow
Yes, you can have multiple policies of different types. Many people combine them for more coverage.

What happens if I miss a premium payment?

up-arrow

The consequences vary by policy type:

  • Term: The policy may lapse after the grace period.
  • TROP: May lose the return of premium benefit.
  • Permanent: May be covered by cash value temporarily.

What should I consider when choosing a policy start date?

up-arrow
When choosing a policy start date, consider the length of the waiting period and your current health status. Starting the policy sooner can help you get through the waiting period earlier, ensuring you have full coverage when needed.

Can I cancel my life insurance policy?

up-arrow

Yes, but the outcomes vary:

  • Term: Coverage ends with no value.
  • TROP: Surrender value may be available.
  • Permanent: Receive cash surrender value minus fees.

Other Important Term Insurance Guides

Limited Pay vs Regular Pay Term Insurance
Can I Buy Multiple Term Insurance Policies?
Questions to Ask Before Buying Term Insurance
Common Mistakes Buying Term Insurance
How to Claim Term Insurance After Death
Is Term Insurance a Smart Investment?
Buying Term Insurance with Passive Income
Smoking After Buying Term Insurance
Term Life Insurance After Divorce
Term Insurance for Financial Security
How Does Term Insurance Work?
Term Insurance FAQs
Online Term Insurance vs Offline Term Insurance
Medical History in Term Insurance
Single vs Joint Term Life Insurance
Term Insurance Myths
Increase Coverage with Term Insurance Riders
Best Time to Buy Term Insurance
How Age Affects Term Insurance Premiums
Personal Accident Insurance Vs Term Insurance
Factors for Buying a Term Plan
Is Income Proof Mandatory for Term Insurance?
How to Buy Term Insurance Online?
Term Insurance Tax Benefits
Telemedical Questions for Term Insurance
Reduce Term Life Insurance Premium
Loan Against Term Life Insurance
Should I Surrender My Term Insurance?
Does Term Insurance cover Accidental Death
Evaluate Term Insurance Quote
Mistakes While Buying Term Insurance
How to Choose Term Insurance Plan
Term Insurance vs Endowment Plan
Why Term Insurance is Important?
Choosing the Duration of Term Insurance
Term Insurance Vs Money Back Insurance
Benefits of Add-ons in Term Insurance
Is Term Insurance Claim Amount Taxable
Pay Term Insurance Till 60 Years
Reasons for Term Insurance Claim Rejection
Accidental Death Coverage in Term Insurance
Outliving Term Life Insurance
Is Buying a Term Plan Good or Bad Idea?
Term Insurance vs Whole Life Insurance
Single Premium vs Regular Premium
Buying Term Insurance at Young Age
Types of Premium Payment in Term Plan
Benefits of Buying Term Insurance Plan
Income Eligibility for Term Insurance
How to Buy Term Insurance Policy?
Term Insurance Terminology Explained
Types of Term Life Insurance
Term Insurance Eligibility
Is Term Insurance Valid Outside India
Compare Term Life Insurance
Pure Term vs TROP vs Permanent Term Insurance

Other Important Articles Related to Term Insurance

5 Crore Term Insurance Plan
Term Insurance with Limited Premium Payment
Single Premium Term Insurance
Term Insurance for Heart Patients
What is Term Plan with Return of Premium (TROP): Features and Benefits
Term Insurance with Monthly Pay Cheque
Types of Riders in Term Insurance Plan
Term Insurance Calculator
Increasing Term Insurance Plan
Term Insurance for Diabetics
Critical Illness Rider in Term Insurance
Term Plan Coverage Till 100 Years
Term Insurance with Critical Illness Cover
Term Insurance for Parents
Accidental Death Benefit Rider
₹50 Lakh Term Insurance
₹10 Crore Term Insurance Plan
Term Insurance for Housewife
5 to 40 Year Term Insurance Plans
Term Insurance for NRIs
Regular Premium Term Insurance
Term Insurance with Maturity Benefits
What is Direct Term Life Insurance?
How Much Term Insurance Cover Do I Need?
Term Insurance Coverage for Every Age
MWP Act in Term Insurance
Benefits of Group Term Life Insurance
Term Insurance for Disable Person
Term Insurance for Single Women
₹2 Crore Term Insurance Plan
Family Term Insurance Plan
Change Nominee in Term Insurance
Premium Paying Term (PPT) in Term Plan
Term Insurance Guides
Compare Term Insurance Plans
Features of Term Insurance
Term Insurance for Self-Employed/Freelancers
Term Life Insurance Durations
10 Year Term Insurance Plan
Convertible Term Life Insurance Policy
75 Lakh Term Insurance
Waiver of Premium Rider in Term Insurance
Income Benefit Rider
₹1 Crore Term Insurance Plan
Term Plan with Return of Premium
Cheap Term Life Insurance
Term Life Insurance for Young Professionals
Joint Term Insurance Plan
Term Insurance for Home Loan

Disclaimer

up-arrow

  • This is an informative article provided on 'as is' basis for awareness purpose only and not intended as a professional advice. The content of the article is derived from various open sources across the Internet. Digit Life Insurance is not promoting or recommending any aspect in the article or its correctness. Please verify the information and your requirement before taking any decisions.
  • All the figures reflected in the article are for illustrative purposes. The premium for Coverage that one buys depends on various factors including customer requirements, eligibility, age, demography, insurance provider, product, coverage amount, term and other factors
  • Tax Benefits, if applicable depend on the Tax Regime opted by the individual and the applicable tax provision. Please consult your Tax consultant before making any decision.

Latest News

Currently there are no news to show.

Read More

Renew & Download Policy Document, Check Challan, Credit Score, PUC & more

Anytime, Anywhere. Only on Digit App!

google-play-icon

Rated App

app-store-icon

Rated App

Download the App