Renew Car Insurance

9000+ Cashless Garages

96% Claims Settled (FY 23-24)

Differences Between Sports Cars vs Muscle Cars

Outright advancements in the automotive sector have allowed car manufacturers to introduce exciting vehicles that differ from conventional cars. Muscle cars and sports cars have dedicated fanbases.

Widely loved for their unmatched aesthetics and top-end specifications, both these vehicles are like dream machines for most car owners. However, if you plan on buying one, which one should you choose?

Go through the detailed comparison between a muscle car and a sports car below and make an informed decision.

Team Digit

What are Sports Cars and Muscle Cars?
History and Evolution
Key Differences
Which Should You Choose?
List of Top Sports Cars
List of Top Muscle Cars
Future Trends
Frequently Asked Questions

What are Sports Cars and Muscle Cars?

If you compare with other mainstream private cars, sports cars and muscle cars beat them by a fair margin. Additionally, if you consider the engine power for these two highlighted vehicle types, they will be the go-to picks for car enthusiasts.

Sports cars and muscle cars belong to the same group of cars. However, they have many different traits which make them unique.

Sports Cars

Comparing the two, sports cars are more aerodynamic and fuel efficient. Additionally, car manufacturers produce them while being mindful of precision handling requirements. These cars boast impressive cornering capabilities at high speeds, which truly keep you grounded on the road. This helps enhance your overall driving experience.

A few key highlights about sports cars are provided below:

Performance

Known for their top speeds, sports cars deviate from their traditional versions, as is unlikely in today’s muscle cars, which differ less from their earlier models.

Handling

While driving a sports car, you should expect nothing less than highly responsive cornering and sharp steering. These two characteristics are the most pronounced features that set sports cars apart from other car types.

Fuel Efficiency

You get better mileage while driving a sports car than muscle cars.

Examples

Some world-famous examples of sports cars are the Porsche 911, Chevrolet Corvette, Mazda MX-5 Miata, Aston Martin V8 Vantage and Ferrari 250 GTO.

Muscle Cars

Muscle cars were originally developed in America between the 1960s and 1970s and are more about raw power and wide tyres. They are typically designed to achieve high speeds on straight lines and do not specialise in cornering like sports cars.

There’s a common saying that goes, “All muscle cars are sports cars, but not all sports cars are muscle cars.”

Some unique aspects of muscle cars are as follows:

Performance

Powered by a hefty V8 engine, a muscle car can produce tremendous straight-line speed. However, some models may be slightly disadvantaged due to the all-important power-to-weight ratio, whereas sports cars often prove more practical.

Handling

Although drivers do not face manoeuvrability issues when driving muscle cars, they may struggle while taking tight turns as these four-wheelers are not as agile as sports cars.

Fuel Efficiency

Car lovers who go for muscle cars tend to prioritise other factors over this aspect when selecting a vehicle model.

Examples

The most popular muscle car models include the Chevrolet Camaro, Ford Mustang Shelby GT500, Dodge Challenger, Pontiac Catalina, and Buick GNX.

History and Evolution of Sports and Muscle Cars

Over the last 100 years, world-class car manufacturers of sports and muscle cars shifted gears. Consistent developments in car engines, aerodynamics, horsepower, and exterior aesthetics have further enhanced these cars’ appeal over time.

Below, we have structured together a detailed analysis of this evolution in the following sections:

Evolution of Sports Cars

1910: First sports car - Mercedes Benz Classic with a 16-valve engine (160 Kmph).
1930: BNC-type sports car - Introduced the V-8 engine with 225 Kmph top speed.
1948: Ferrari 16MM Barchetta - A two-door, five-speed manual transmission sports car with a 209 Kmph top speed.
1966: Ford GT40 MK 1 – Came with a V-8 engine that could accelerate from 0 to 96 Kmph in just 5.1 seconds.
1972: Lamborghini Miura – Lamborghini’s first-ever sports car with an all-wheel drivetrain that could achieve a top speed of 300 Kmph.
1992: McLaren F1 - Boasted a horsepower of 550 per ton and came with two passenger seats.
2008: Chevy Corvette Z06 – The iconic three-door coupe with a top speed of 319 Kmph.
2015: McLaren P1 - An ultimate, advanced sports car with a 3.8-liter V-8 engine.

Evolution of Muscle Cars

1949: First Muscle Car: Oldsmobile introduced the ‘Rocket’, that could produce a commendable output of 135 HP.
1951: Hornet: Hudson Motor Car Company introduced the ‘Hornet’ which still maintains its legendary status as a leading race car.
1964: Pontiac GTO - Featured a much larger engine size and improved aesthetics, which dominated the image of muscle cars in the public's eye.
1970s: Downfall - The Federal Government acknowledged the Clean Air Act and most car insurance companies started charging higher premiums to those who owned a muscle car.
1980s and Onwards: Revival - With the latest innovations and improved fuel injection methodologies, muscle cars started making a strong comeback in the mainstream.

Key Differences Between Muscle Cars and Sports Cars

Apart from the general differences stated above, the following are the key differences between muscle cars and sports cars:

Parameter	Sports Car	Muscle Car
Engine Size	Sports cars are made with varying engines. They can have anything from V-10 to straight-four engines, which ensure better cornering and control.	Typically feature V-8 engines that are reputed for exemplary performance.
Torque	Selective sports cars can use external means like a turbo or nitromethane engine to enhance their power.	Muscle car engines directly transmit power to the car wheels.
Body Style and Design	Sports cars are all about stylish looks and top-notch aerodynamics. Their sleek bodies and slim frames make room for enhanced manoeuvrability and cornering.	Muscle cars occupy more road space because they need to accommodate larger engines. Thus, they have a tough, commanding outlook with broad panels.
Handling	For better handling and greater command, while driving, sports cars have the edge.	If your focus is getting superior straight-line acceleration, no other car types can compete with muscle cars.
Cost of Ownership	Sports cars have smaller engines and are designed to be more fuel-efficient. Hence, these vehicles are cheaper to maintain overall.	Muscle cars are larger with powerful engines, often attracting higher insurance premiums. Furthermore, they typically require more fuel for operation, thus increasing the cost of ownership.

Muscle Car vs Sports Car: Which Should You Choose?

It is incredibly challenging to decide between these two highly desirable car types. However, you can ask yourself the following questions to decide whether a muscle car or a sports car will best suit your needs:

What Type of Exterior Appeals to You More?

If you prioritise a sleek finish, sports cars are the way to go! Alternatively, if you prefer a vehicle with bold looks and a striking road presence, then you should pick a muscle car.

How Fast are You Willing to Go on Road Turns?

If you live in an area where it is possible to take frequent sharp turns, sports cars can give you limitless enjoyable rides. On the other hand, muscle cars are made for driving in straight routes and are not that reputed for precision cornering and handling.

What Kind of Engine are You Looking for?

Generally fitted with V-8 engines, muscle cars offer unmatched revs. However, if you are not looking for such incredible power and are more into swift driving, then you may choose sports cars instead.

What’s Your Budget?

Sports cars are relatively cheaper and attract lower maintenance costs. However, you can compare the prices of popular models of both types online before making a well-informed decision.

List of Top Sports Cars in India

Some of the best petrol-powered sports cars in India are as follows:

Mercedes-AMG SL55 Roadster
Porsche 911 Carrera
BMW M4 Competition
Porsche 718 Cayman
BMW Z4

List of Top Muscle Cars in India

Listed below are the top 5 muscle cars in India:

Lexus RC F
Mercedes-AMG C63 S Coupe
Ford Mustang Shelby GT500
Chevrolet Camaro SS
Dodge Challenger R/T

Future Trends of Sports and Muscle Cars

For Sports Cars

Fully electric sports cars have emerged over the past decade and are rapidly gaining popularity. Some of the most popular models in this regard include the Porsche Taycan, Rimac Nevera, Pininfarina Battista, Tesla Model S Plaid, Audi RS e-tron GT, and Lucid Air Sapphire.

With more mechanical innovations and a responsive driving experience, electric sports cars are set to drive the future of the automobile market.

For Muscle Cars

As far as muscle cars are concerned, 2023 has already bid farewell to many iconic models. However, a few top-selling models, such as the Ford Mustang, Dodge Charger, Chevrolet Camaro, and so on, continue to exist.

A few of the above-mentioned muscle cars are about to line up for Hurricane i6 engines, which will surpass the V-8 engine’s performance. Additionally, a new era of such vehicles will be ushered in with the introduction of e-muscle cars like the Ford Mustang Mach E.

Now that you have a clear idea of the key differences between muscle cars and sports cars, you are ready to make an informed purchase decision. Both vehicle types have unique features. So, weigh out their pros and cons and see whether they align with your preferences before making your decision.

Key Factors to Consider Before Buying an SUV or Crossover

Form Factor: If you want a vehicle with a compact form factor, crossovers should be your pick.
Off-roading: In case you wish to use your car for frequent off-roading, SUVs will be the better choice.
Boot Space: If a large boot space is your primary requirement, SUVs can be an ideal option.
Towing: In case you want your car to have towing capabilities, SUVs should be your pick.
Fuel Efficiency: If fuel efficiency is your concern, crossovers will be the better option.

FAQs about Sports Cars and Muscle Cars

All

Are muscle cars faster than sports cars?

Muscle cars can beat sports cars when you compare both of their straight-line speed capabilities. However, when it comes to precisely hugging the turns, sports cars have an edge.

Which is more affordable to maintain: a muscle car or a sports car?

Maintenance affordability in the long run mainly depends on a car model and not a specific class of cars (e.g., muscle cars or sports cars). Hence, to predict maintenance costs accurately, you must conduct thorough research while purchasing.

Can a muscle car handle as well as a sports car?

When it comes to agility and cornering ability, muscle cars cannot handle as well as sports cars. However, these vehicles can achieve tremendous speeds when you drive them in a straight line.

Which is better for long drives: a muscle car or a sports car?

Owing to the fuel-efficient nature of sports cars, these are a far superior choice compared to muscle cars in long drives. Also, they are easy to manoeuvre on winding roads and offer safe, quiet and comfortable rides.

Are muscle cars fuel-efficient?

Most muscle cars tend to have larger engines compared to sports cars. As a result, they are expected to consume more petrol while driving.

Do muscle cars or sports cars hold value better over time?

A well-maintained muscle car can hold its value better compared to any other sports car over the years. This is because muscle cars maintain a strong collector base internationally and can evoke nostalgia within a specific car market.

Which vehicle type is best for drag racing?

Owing to their strong acceleration capabilities and powerful engines, muscle cars are the best suited for drag racing.

What is the future of muscle cars and sports cars with electric vehicles?

The future prospects of muscle and sports cars with electric vehicles lie in blending classic performance with advanced electric drivetrains. The unique innovations will give rise to instant torque, eco-friendliness, and great designs while preserving the muscle car's iconic appeal through electrified models and sustainable engineering.